Handbook for journalists for free access to public information – Legal Leaks Toolkit (in Macedonian)
Handbook for journalists for free access to public information - Legal Leaks Toolkit (in Macedonian)
Handbook for journalists for free access to public information - Legal Leaks Toolkit (in Macedonian)
The EU-funded project improved and raised awareness about the importance of having greater access for journalists to public information in order to increase the quality of public information and to promote freedom of expression and independent media.
Being an advocate for transparency, accountability and responsibility of the institutions, the Center for Civil Communications remains dedicated to the efforts for strengthening the role of the media in society, bearing in mind that they are of vital importance for the democracy and for creating conditions for a responsible and accountable working of the government officials.
Since November 2008, the Center for Civil Communications from Skopje has continuously analyzed the implementation of the public procurement process in the Republic of Macedonia as regulated with the Public Procurement Law.
The Project developed mechanisms for increasing transparency, accountability and responsibility of local government in Macedonia, encouraging greater participation of citizens and local business community in the decision-making process in local government and the exchange of best practices and experiences among municipalities in the country, and in the region.
The Center for Civil Communications has announced today the results of the regular monitoring of public procurements in the country, for the period of April – June 2012.
From November 2008, the Centre for Civil Communications from Skopje has continuously analysed the implementation of public procurements in the Republic of Macedonia as regulated under the Law on Public Procurement.
This report is prepared on the basis of monitoring results developed for 40 public procurements included in the monitoring sample and implemented by local institutions throughout Macedonia in the period 1 April – 30 September 2013.
The fifth Index of Rationality is developed for the following five types of products, i.e., services: commission rates charged by Agencies for Temporary Employment; ISO 9001 Quality Management System Standards; antifreeze liquid; carwash services; and bottled still water.
Водич за невладини организации за борба против корупцијата
The present research and analysis targets public procurement performance and practices implemented by 21 municipalities in Macedonia, i.e., ¼ of all municipalities in the country.
The Center for Civil Communications organised a second workshop on July 4 to discuss crucial measures necessary to decrease the level of corruption, this time with focus on public enterprises and institutions.
Download here: Proposals for Amendments to the Public Procurement Law
The Handbook can be found here: Прирачник за новинари истражување и известување за јавните набавки
Detailed recommendations aimed to improve the public procurement system
Прирачник за новинари за известување за јавните набавки албански јазик: Doracak për gazetarë për hulumtim dhe raportim në lidhje me furnizimet publike
1. It is obligatory for the managers in the public enterprises and institutions to be elected through a public announcement of a vacancy and according to their qualifications and competence; 2.The institution “manager contract” should be consistently used and respected, in which the rights, duties, and responsibilities of the managerial work will be clearly specified; 3.There should be more detailed conditions and criteria that need to be fulfilled in order for one person to be...
There are no translations available. Прирачник за новинари за истражување и известување за корупција
Manual оn Reporting about Local Issues and Investigative Reporting
Printed version of the publication is here: Index of Rationality 3 and 4 Тhe fourth Index of Rationality is developed for the following five types of products, i.e. services: - website design;- firewood;- behaton paving elements;- health examination for employees;- fire-fighting protection.
1. To disable the builder of an illegal construction in the period until the legalization or demolishing of that construction to enjoy legal protection that is bestowed on an owner, by means of changes in the Ownership Law and other rights; 2. Urban plans should be used for planning spaces rather than legalizing illegal constructions, i.e. confirming the existing condition; 3. To disable retroactive issuing of permits for constructing buildings that are already built; 4....
1. Revoking the discretionary right of the public institutions managers to choose one of the first five best ranked candidates submitted by the Agency for state employees and establishing an obligation to hire the first ranked candidate; 2. Every state institution to publish on its web site the systematization of work places (on the institution’s web page); 3. To reexamine the exemption of the employees in the Customs administration and the Public Revenue Office from...
Policy Brief: Suggestions for amendments to the Law on Free Access to Public Information and for enhancing its application on the part of journalists
The project analyses the spending of public money in Macedonia in terms of transparency, competition and equal treatment of companies, non-discrimination, economic, efficient, effective and rational use of public funds, the endeavor to get the best offer under the most favorable conditions as well as accountability for public spending.
There are no translations available 1. Да се воведе задолжителна анти-корупциска настава во основното образование за поимот и видовите на корупција, како и за штетните последици од неа; 2. Да се воведат антикорупциски одредби во законите за образование со кои ќе се спречуваат конфликтот на интерес, непотизмот, кронизмот, забрана за вршење образовна работа за лица за кои со судска пресуда биде утврдено дека земале поткуп и сл. 3. Да се воспостават строги критериуми за...
A group of Macedonian journalists were acquainted with the practices and experiences of their Bulgarian colleagues and experts on how to inform better the public through the application of the Law on Free Access to Public Information, during a three-day study visit to Bulgaria.
The project facilitates micro and small enterprise (MSE) access to public procurement market, by increasing MSEs’ capacities and removing the barriers for their greater participation in public tenders.
The project encompassed a series of separate and joint activities for enhancing media and CSOs role, as the most important representatives of the citizens, in the fight against corruption.
Decreasing the corruption: Exchange of experiences and best practices in investigative journalism among journalists from Macedonia and Romania
The project enhances the journalistic standards for investigating and reporting on corruption and strengthens the capacity of the media for accomplishing their role in the fight against corruption.
After determining the most vulnerable areas to corruption in Macedonia in the first phase of the project, by means of this project a total of 156 concrete measures that need to be taken by the authorities were created and recommended in order to narrow the room for corruption. The project included a comparison with the best practices from other countries, a series of workshops on which experts and representatives from the interested parties discussed and...
As part of the project, a total of 68 journalists from 16 local TV stations from all cities in Macedonia were trained. The trainings took place on the very spot in the newsrooms of the local media, as well as on the field during their everyday work. They were directed toward enhancing the skills of the journalists for focusing their stories on the interest of the citizens from the local community and toward improving the...
The trainers from the Center conducted four regional trainings for about 30 journalists from the local media in order to enhance their abilities and capacities for researching and reporting on the work of the local government in light of the increased authorities of the local government, and in its turn the increased role of the local media for reporting on issues of interest of the citizens in the municipalities. The training also resulted in devising...
In fact, this project meant implementing the individual action plans of the representatives of the Center, who devised them during the training for improving the capacity for fighting against corruption, conducted by international experts of Crown Agents. Within the project, the Center trained a group of 8 journalists from leading local media for investigating and reporting on corruption, who then came up with their own investigative stories based on what they had learned and on...
The project encompassed in-depth investigations on corruption in several most vulnerable areas: public procurements, the composition of the management committees of public enterprises, providing services from the public administration, construction, education, and health care. The results from the investigation were published in analytical reports regarding the level, forms, and generators of corruption. The reports received wide coverage by the Macedonian media, with a total of 108 journalistic reports. Instigated by the reports, governmental representatives announced...
Look at what the media have said and written about our work. News articles are grouped per year. 2026 2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2006 – 2008
In this issue Two powerful institutions, the World Bank and United Nations took advantage of the International Anti-Corruption Day – December 9 – to send rather strong messages for strengthening the fight against corruption.
The project aimed at strengthening of civil society pressure on the authorities of the countries of the Western Balkans, in order to establish an efficient system of public procurement and accountability in the expenditure of public funds.
In this issueFormer minister of defense and deputy of the ruling party in Croatia and ex-US vice president are being investigated in corruption-related cases – the first one for alleged illegal public procurement and the latter for bribing a Nigerian national in business matters linked to natural gas.
In this issue The corruption has deeply entered the sport arena. Even the top sports are affected. The World Football Federation had to suspend two of its members from the top management after it was revealed that they sold their votes during the process of selecting the location for the next football world championship.
Corruption in the private sector and its combating is an increasingly debated topic worldwide, a topic that was tackled in one of the prior issues of the monthly newsletter.
In this issueAlmost hundred defendants, including former mayors, former city officials, entrepreneurs, lawyers and art dealers face possible jail terms amounting to a total of up to 500 years and fines totaling about one billion euros in Spain's biggest ever corruption trial.
The Center for Civil Communications published findings from their monitoring of public procurement procedures that were implemented by local government institutions between April and September 2012.
In this issue Several non-governmental in Serbia have decided to ‘whistle’ against corruption. They have launched a special web portal that offers opportunity to citizens to report corruption, namely to blow the whistle, while journalists engaged in this project will further investigate these reports and alarm the public.
Just two months since you have read on these very same pages an exclusive interview with the leading regional anti-corruptioner, the head of Slovene Commission for Preventing Corruption and Chairperson of the Council of Europe’s Group of States against Corruption (GRECO), Drago Kos, we present yet another exclusive interview in this issue.
In this issue:You have the latest issue of the Anti-Corruption newsletter (MAK). First of all we wish to thank to all of those who responded to our poll by which we wish to hear how satisfied you are with our newsletter and collect your proposals, suggestions for its further development.
The Center for Civil Communications was established in April 2005 as a nongovernmental, nonparty, and nonprofit association of citizens. In the past five years we have been working every day on narrowing the room for corruption in Macedonia and promoting the principles of “good governance”, both on central and local level.
Starting from March 1 this year, every citizen of the European Union will be able to anonymously report any suspicion on fraud and corruption on Internet, through the new electronic system of the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF).
There are no translations available Препораки за унапредување на транспарентното и отчетното локално владеење
Corruption is a problem in the countries in our immediate surroundings. This issue provides a deeper insight in the situation in Kosovo. The anti-corruption agency in Kosovo has filed charges against 159 officers on suspicion of corruption.
Corruption is widespread everywhere in the world, especially in the Balkans region. The citizens of Monte Negro believe that it is present in the health care the most, in Serbia, as of this year, the Agency for Fighting against Corruption started working, while the newly elected president of Croatia won as an anticorruption candidate.
In the course of our everyday work, we and the experts we cooperate with arrive at numerous information regarding corruption and anticorruption practices in our country, as well as the countries in the region and the world.
This Index of Rationality is developed for a group of five products purchased by national and local level institutions in the course of 2012, those being: copy paper; industrial salt; extra light fuel oil (EL-1); air-conditioners; and calico bandages.
Monitoring of the Media Reporting on Corruption in Macedonia 2011KEY FINDINGS The corruption as a topic is relatively frequent in the media. The corruption is not present on the front pages or the first minutes of the newscast. The corruption stories are dominantly not announced at the front pages or in the breaking news.
Monitoring of the media reporting on corruption in Macedonia 2009 The articles on corruption published from January 1 to December 31, 2008 in five daily newspapers (“Dnevnik”, “Vecer”, “Vreme”, “Utrinski Vesnik”, and “Fakti” 1) were subject to direct monitoring.
Index of Rationality 3 Printed version of the publication is here: Index of Rationality 3 and 4 The third Index of Rationality is developed for the following five types of products, i.e. services: - written translation from Macedonian into English language; - air-conditioners; - private security services; - notebook computers; - GPS vehicle devices.
One of the main goals of decentralisation is to make the local authorities more responsive to the needs of the local communities. Still, six years after the start of the process, surveys show that citizens remain unsatisfied with the manner in which the local self-government deals with their problems and how it organizes the life and work of local communities.
The Center for Civil Communications submitted the measures for narrowing the room for corruption in the public administration to the authorized institutions and media in the country.
The Index of Rationality for the second group of products (second quarterly report) was developed by means of comparing purchase prices paid for medical disposables used in the health care sector. In order to provide a better overview of the state of affairs in this sector, the Index was developed for six types of products, those being:- transfusion kits;- infusion kits;- syringes;- cotton wads;- cotton patches; and- calico bandages.
The Center for Civic Communications presented the fourth quarterly Report on the results of the public procurement process monitoring, which besides the regular analysis of public procurement procedures, also contains an analysis of the legal protection in the public procurement procedures.
Results of the survey of existing practices in municipalities in Eastern Macedonia: Štip, Strumica, Sveti Nikole and Vinica The NGO Infocentre, Centre for Civil Communications and EHO implement the „USAID Project for Transparent Governance“, in the period September 2009-August 2012.
This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements.
The Center for Civil Communications has been working on systematizing and prioritizing the measures for narrowing the room for corruption in the education, proposed at the workshop that took place on 16 January 2008.
The complete politicization of the management boards of the public enterprises and institutions at state and local level, which is carried through at the expense of the expertise and competence of their members, is evaluated, both by domestic experts and international organizations, as a condition which enables corruption and contributes to the further development of this problem.
The first Quarterly Analysis of the results from the monitoring of the implementation of the public procurement procedures in the Republic of Macedonia on central level was published on February 26, 2009. The Center for Civil Communications is analyzing the implementation of the public procurement procedures trough 4 phases in the period November 2008 – November 2009. The goal of the analysis is to assess the implementation of the public procurement procedures in the RoM in light of the new PPL and to determine if and to what extent the following basic public procurement principles have been followed and applied: transparency, competitiveness, equal treatment of the economic operators, non-discrimination, legality, efficient, effective and rational spending of the Budget (best value for the money), as well as accountability of the money spent.
The sluggishness of the administration on both state and local levels, the ambiguous criteria for the approval of permits and licences, the broad area for arbitrary deciding, as well as the non - transparent acts represent the key generators of corruption in the process of providing services to the citizens on the part of the municipal and state administrations.
More than 10,000 illegally built constructions in the Republic of Macedonia, which have sprung under the very eyes of the Construction Inspection since the year 2 000 up to now, have been the subject of corruption activities in several stages, starting with their construction and concluding with their final legalization.
Despite the very small number of officially reported and solved cases, corruption in the education of the Republic of Macedonia not only exists, but it exists in the entire educational system. In contrast to the very few officially reported cases, there is a perception in the public that the corruption in the education is a widespread phenomenon, especially in the university education.
The health care sector in the Republic of Macedonia is seriously endangered by various forms of corruption which take place in two segments: corruption in the supply of medicines, medical materials, and equipment and corruption in the provision of health services.
In the public procurement business, which on a state and local level is estimated at more than one billion euros a year, elaborate, tried and tested schemes of corruption are hidden.
Радио Слободна Европа, 24.01.2013, Народната каса нетранспарентно се празни Нова Македонија, 29.12.2012, Државата потрошила над 30 милиони евра на набавки без тендер Миа, 28.12.2012, Анализа: Се зголемува проблемот со поништувањето на поголемите тендери Бриф, 28.12.2012, Се повеќе се зголемува проблемот со поништување на поголемите тендери Капитал, 28.12.2012, ЦГК:За девет месеци договорени јавни набавки во четри очи вредни 32 милиони евра Фактор, 28.12.2012, Без оглас договорени јавни набавки вредни 14 милиони евра Плус Инфо, 28.12.2012, Продолжуваат јавните набавки во четри очи Скај, 28.12.2012, Набавките...
More than 30 participants discussed the results of a recent Monitoring of media coverage of corruption in the country, on two workshops held in Skopje on September 30, and October 4.
The analysis of the public procurement process in the Republic of Macedonia was performed based on the monitoring of randomly selected sample of public procurement procedures (40 of each quarter).
The analysis of the public procurement process in the Republic of Macedonia was performed based on the monitoring of randomly selected sample of public procurementprocedures (40 per quarter). Monitoring activities start with the publication of calls for bids in the “Official Gazette of theRepublic of Macedonia”, followed by attendance on public opening of bids and data collection on the procedure course,and use in-depth interviews and structured questionnaires submitted to the economic operators, as well as data obtained from contracting authorities by means of Freedomof Information (FOI) applications. The present analysis was performed based on monitoringof selected sample of 40 public procurement proceduresimplemented by central level contracting authorities, whosepublic opening of bids took place in the period April – June 2011.
First Quarterly Report 2011 The present analysis was performed based on monitoringof selected sample of 40 public procurement proceduresimplemented by central level contracting authorities, whosepublic opening of bids took place in the period January –March 2011.
Eligibility criteria for companies to participate intender procedures limit competition and favour certain bidders.
Дневник, 24.12.2010, Во четири очи договорени 20 милиони евра буџетски пари Радио Северна Европа, 23.12.2010, Злоупотреба на тендерите? Дневник, 22.12.2010, Конкуренцијата на тендерите се помала Нова Македонија, 22.12.2010, За три месеци потрошиле над 9 милиони евра Време, 22.12.2010, Поништените тендери станаа тренд Вечер, 22.12.2010, Извештај на ЦГК: Зголемен уделот на поништени тендери Утрински, 22.12.2010, Тендерите ја задушуваат конкуренцијата Бизнис, 22.12.2010, Во непосредни договори потрошени 9,3 милиони евра МК Фондови,22.12.2010, Расте недовербата во постапките за јавни набавки Дејли,22.12.2010, Расте недовербата во постапките за јавни набавки Запирка,...
The Center for Civil Communications published the results from the regular public procurements monitoring in the country and the results from the survey of companies about their experience with the public procurement procedures.
Center for Civil Communications presented the results of the monitoring of the media reporting on corruption in Macedonia on June 30, 2009. Representative of the CCC, German Filkov, presented the results of the monitoring and led discussions on with the most relevant representatives of the Macedonian media. Besides presenting the results of the monitoring, the workshop with the editors helped to emerge common recommendations for improving the way in which media reports about this very serious problem, that will enhance their role in the fight against corruption in Macedonia.
The Center for Civil communications presented The second quarterly report based on the monitoring of the public procurements process on June 23, 2009.
Monitoring on public procurement on local government level No.6 The Centre for Civil Communications (CCC) is regularly monitoring the implementation of public procurement procedures in Macedonia from 2008 onwards, i.e. from the entry in effect of the new Law on Public Procurement, drafted in line with the European Commission’s Directives. The purpose of monitoring activities is to assess whether and to what extent state institutions adhere to the general principles underlying public spending, as stipulated...
The annual report summarizes the monitoring results and reiterates the 10 key findings common for the previous four quarterly monitoring reports. The report also provides the key recommendations aimed to amend the relevant legislation and/or to improve the enforcement thereof.
Handbook for contracting authorities on participation in public tenders
Every fourth public procurement contract from the monitoring sample was signed in a tender procedure with only one bidding company. Lack of competition among companies results in no guarantees that public funds are spent for quality goods and services offered at favourable, competitive prices.
The Center for Civil Communications has announced today the Index of rationality 8 which compares prices by which different state institutions on central and local level buy the very same products and services.
Center for Civil Communications, together with BIRN Macedonia and the Centre for Investigative journalism, SCOOP Macedonia launched a call for investigative stories on May 17.